8:00am

Wed August 3, 2011
U.S.

FAA Operations Up In The Air Amid Shutdown

Originally published on Wed August 3, 2011 11:42 am

A partial shutdown of the Federal Aviation Administration, prompted by a political dispute, is adding to the country's debt. This month alone, that shutdown will cost the Treasury $1 billion in uncollected airline ticket taxes.

The shutdown is happening because of a labor dispute, a long-standing rivalry and a disagreement over subsidizing small airports. It's not clear when it will all be resolved now that members of Congress are leaving Washington, D.C., for their summer recess.

NPR's Renee Montagne talks to NPR's Brian Naylor about what's behind the standoff.

Renee Montagne: First off, we understand the FAA is running air traffic control and other essential safety functions — that's right?

Brian Naylor: That's right. We should say at the top, all the nation's air traffic controllers have been on the job and will continue to be. And there's no disruption in the nation's air traffic. FAA officials say safety is their top priority. The controllers are considered essential employees, and their jobs have been unaffected by all this.

Montagne: And aside from the federal government losing taxes on this, what effect does this partial shutdown have?

Naylor: It's been hard to detect by the average traveler. I think maybe [that's] one reason why this dispute has lasted as long as it has. There are some 4,000 FAA employees who are on furlough now, not collecting their paychecks. In addition, there are, according to the administration, about 70,000 construction workers who've been working on projects like runway extensions and constructing control towers — all of those projects have been put on hold, and so all of those workers have been idled by this dispute. So that's the biggest effect, but it's not something that a lot of people will notice.

Montagne: And those airline ticket taxes going uncollected — could the government recover that money later?

Naylor: No, that money is lost, never to be seen again — $30 million a day, maybe, as you said, over a billion dollars in lost revenues to the government should this dispute last into next month, as it may well do.

Montagne: Give us some more details on the issues keeping the two sides apart.

Naylor: It's complex. The FAA usually gets authorized several years in advance because, like the highway bill, a lot of these projects have long lead times. And the last authorization expired in 2007. And Congress hasn't been able to agree on a new long-term reauthorization, so it's passed a series of temporary reauthorizations — 20 to be exact. And among the reasons the two sides can't agree on a long-term measure is a provision House Republicans want to include — it would make it harder for airline and railroad employees to form a union. But they didn't include that on the last proposal for another temporary extension.

What's gumming up the works on another temporary bill — and we're talking about a six-week extension — on the temporary bill, Republicans want to roll back a program called Essential Air Service, which subsidizes a bunch of small, regional airports. It just so happens those airports that would be cut from the program are in the states of some powerful Senate Democrats, including West Virginia Sen. Jay Rockefeller, who just happens to chair the Senate committee with authority over the FAA.

Montagne: So it sounds like Republicans and Democrats are both involved, but who are the major players who don't want to make a permanent deal?

Naylor: Well, it's Rockefeller and his House counterpart, Republican John Mica — they're the two key players. Mica's insistence on trimming back the air subsidy in any new temporary bill, and Rockefeller's refusal to buckle is what's keeping this from happening.

Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood, who's a former Republican congressmen, knows both men well and has met with both of them, and I think is very frustrated that neither is willing to bend. And it looks like this dispute is going to continue into September before it's resolved. In the meantime, some 74,000 FAA employees and contractors won't be getting paychecks.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

RENEE MONTAGNE, host:

Here's another thing that's adding to the country's debt: A partial shutdown of the Federal Aviation Administration. This month alone, that shutdown will cost the Treasury a billion dollars in airline ticket taxes. The shutdown is happening because of a labor dispute, a longstanding rivalry, and a disagreement over subsidizing small airports. It's not clear when it all will be resolved, now that members of Congress are leaving Washington, D.C. for their summer recess.

NPR's Brian Naylor has been following this story. Good morning, Brian.

BRIAN NAYLOR: Good morning, Renee.

MONTAGNE: You know, first off, we understand the FAA's running air traffic control and other essentials, safety functions. That's right.

NAYLOR: That's right. We should say at the top, all the nation's air traffic controllers have been on the job and will continue to be and there's no disruption in the nation's air traffic. FAA officials say safety is their top priority. The controllers are considered essential employees and their jobs have been unaffected by all this.

MONTAGNE: And aside from the federal government losing taxes on this, what affect does this partial shutdown have?

NAYLOR: It's been hard to detect, you know, by the average traveler, and I think maybe one reason why this dispute has lasted as long as it has, there are some 4,000 FAA employees who are on furlough now, not collecting their paychecks. In addition, there are, according to the administration, about 70,000 construction workers who have been working on projects like runway extensions and constructing control towers. All of those projects have been put on hold and so all of those workers have been idled by this dispute. So that's the biggest effect, but it's not something that a lot of people will notice.

MONTAGNE: And those airline ticket taxes going uncollected, could the government recover that money later?

NAYLOR: No, that money is lost, never to be seen again, $30 million a day, maybe, as you said, over a billion dollars in lost revenues to the government should this dispute last into next month, as it may well do.

MONTAGNE: Well, give us some more details on the issues keeping the two sides apart.

NAYLOR: It's complex. The FAA usually gets authorized several years in advance because, like the highway bill, a lot of these projects have long lead times, and the last authorization expired in 2007 and Congress hasn't been able to agree on a new long-term reauthorization. So it's passed a series of temporary reauthorizations, 20 to be exact.

And among the reasons the two sides can't agree on a long-term measure as a prevision, House Republicans want to include it would make it harder for airline and railroad employees to form a union. But they didn't include that on the last proposal for another temporary extension. What's gumming up the works on another temporary bill, and we're talking about a six week extension, on the temporary bill Republicans want to roll back a program called Essential Air Service, which subsidizes a bunch of small regional airports.

It just so happens those airports that would be cut from the program are in the states of some powerful Senate Democrats, including in West Virginia Senator Jay Rockefeller, who just happens to chair the Senate committee with authority over the FAA.

MONTAGNE: So it sounds like Republicans and Democrats are both involved, but who are the major players who don't want to make a permanent deal?

NAYLOR: Well, it's Rockefeller and his House counterpart, Republican John Mica, are the they're the two key players. Mica's insistence on trimming back the air subsidy in any new temporary bill and Rockefeller's refusal to buckle is what's keeping this from happening. Secretary Ray LaHood is a former Republican congressman, has knows both men well and has met with both of them and I think is very frustrated that neither is willing to bend. And it looks like this dispute is going to continue into September before it's resolved. And in the meantime some 74,000 FAA employees and contractors won't be getting paychecks.

MONTAGNE: NPR's Brian Naylor, thanks very much.

NAYLOR: Thank you, Renee. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Related Program