Around the Nation
A Terrible Winter Wreaks Havoc On Roads, Pipes And City Budgets
Originally published on Thu March 13, 2014 4:43 pm
Bitter cold has returned to parts of the Midwest, mid-Atlantic and Northeast, following another heavy snowstorm that left 1 to 2 feet of snow from Ohio to New England.
And when all this snow finally melts, it'll expose the physical toll of this brutal winter: potholes, broken water mains, collapsed catch basins and other infrastructure problems.
"This winter's crazy, crazy busy," says John Polishak, a foreman for the Chicago Department of Water Management. "Everybody's been working 16 hours a day, seven days a week. It's exhausting."
Polishak is supervising a small crew digging up a snow-covered, frozen parkway in front of a house on Chicago's northwest side. They create a trench more than 5 feet deep to find where a water pipe is leaking.
This is a common problem this winter. Most water pipes in Chicago are buried 5 feet deep, which is usually below the frost line, but record-cold temperatures caused the ground to freeze much deeper than normal.
As the ground freezes, it expands, causing the frozen soil to shift and push against the aging water pipes. That movement can cause the pipes to bend and crack. The same thing has been happening in natural gas pipes, causing a huge increase in gas leaks under city streets this winter.
After removing the rusting piece of water pipe and joint called a "buffalo box," Polishak shows the damage.
"You see how this was supposed to be straight?" he asks, pointing to a slight bend in the pipe. "It literally pulled this thing up, and it broke the joint."
Tom Powers, a Chicago Department of Water Management commissioner, says the biggest problem is that the cold weather "has not let up."
"We've had a very challenging year," he says. Cold and snow have just continued "for another week, and another week, and another week. Here we are in March, and we've had almost three full months of some of the worst weather I've seen in my years with the city of Chicago."
This week's snowstorm, which dumped another several inches on the city, has made this winter the third-snowiest on record. It is also one of the coldest winters ever recorded.
That's led to more frozen water services than any other winter in recent memory, Powers says. "In 2013, we had roughly at this time, round numbers, about a thousand calls. This year it's over 5,200."
As weather starts to warm, another problem develops. The pipes are old — really old — and they can break as the temperature fluctuates back and forth. "We've got 4,400 miles of water main across the city of Chicago; about a quarter of that is 100 years or older," he says.
It's not just water pipes. Aging catch basins and sewer lines are crumbling, too — some of which are so old they're made of brick.
And, of course, potholes are opening up on roads and bridges everywhere.
Already A Problem
This isn't happening just in Chicago. The northern half of the country, and even some parts of the South that were hammered by the rare polar vortex, are feeling it too.
"The infrastructure has taken a beating as a result of this winter, and it was already in a somewhat fragile state before the cold and snow hit," says James Brooks of the National League of Cities. "The general deficit in infrastructure investment existed long before" this winter's harsh weather.
He says the cost of fixing up what the heavy snows and bitter cold have wrecked will be hefty, at a time when many cities' budgets are just as fragile as their infrastructure.
"They had begun to stabilize their financial health only to now be whacked again very hard by the weather — at a time when they do not have the personnel in place, they do not have the equipment in place, and obviously they don't have the resources in place to really be able to address this fully," says Brooks.
The American Society of Civil Engineers agrees that energy, water and transportation infrastructures are in poor shape. Before this brutal winter, the group graded the condition of the nation's infrastructure as a D+. The effects of repeated freeze-thaw cycles, heavy plowing and corrosive road salt exacerbated infrastructure problems, says Andrew Herrmann, a former society president.
"The salt, the chlorides, they just accelerate deterioration," says Herrmann. "They cause the steel [on a girder on a bridge] to rust at a faster rate, they cause it to expand and pop out the concrete if it's in rebar. ... It can cause everything to deteriorate faster."
But, Herrmann says, the chilly clouds that brought all this misery this winter may have a silver lining of sorts: "Though I don't wish a pothole on anyone, I hope it does open [the public's] eyes that, yes, we need to do something about our infrastructure."
Herrmann and others say this is a critical time to make greater investments in infrastructure, because climate change will likely bring more extreme weather and more violent storms.
"We have to make sure that we design our infrastructure ... [to be] more resilient," says Herrmann. "That means, unfortunately, more investment, more dollars put into it."
ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:
From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED, I'm Robert Siegel.
MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:
And I'm Melissa Block. It's back. Winter weather, that is. People in parts of the Midwest, mid-Atlantic and Northeast are digging out from yet another heavy snowstorm. The physical toll of this brutal winter includes potholes, broken water mains and other infrastructure problems. NPR's David Schaper reports from Chicago.
DAVID SCHAPER, BYLINE: The spring sounds of robins chirping, lawnmowers droning, the crack of a baseball bat, those are still a few weeks away in Chicago. Here, we have this reminding us we're still not done yet with the brutal winter. A crew from the gas company is tearing up the street to fix a gas leak underground caused by the deep winter freeze.
And there are other utility crews making emergency winter-related repairs all around the city, including these workers from the city's water department who have dug a deep trench in the frozen parkway to get at a leaking water line.
JOHN POLISHAK: Crazy, crazy busy.
SCHAPER: John Polishak is a foreman for the Chicago Department of Water Management.
POLISHAK: Everybody's been working like 16 hours a day, 7 days a week. It's exhausting.
SCHAPER: Record cold temperatures this winter pushed the frost line more than five feet deep, which is the depth at which most waterlines are buried. As the ground freezes, it expands, pushing the frozen soil against the aging water pipes. Polishak shows me a casualty.
POLISHAK: That little hole, that's the leak.
SCHAPER: He's holding a rusting piece of pipe and joint called a buffalo box.
POLISHAK: You see how this is supposed to be straight? You see how the frost, it literally holds this thing up and it broke the joint.
SCHAPER: That deep frost line is also freezing city water pipes more than any other winter in recent memory, says Chicago water commissioner Tom Power.
TOM POWERS: In 2013, we had roughly, at this time, round numbers, about 1,000 calls. This year, it's over 5,200.
SCHAPER: And Powers says if the weather starts to warm, another problem develops.
POWERS: These aged pipes, when the temperature fluctuates back and forth, we see water main breaks.
SCHAPER: And by aged pipes, Powers means they're really old.
POWERS: We've got 4,400 miles of water main across the city of Chicago, about a quarter of that is 100 years or older.
SCHAPER: And it's not just water pipes, but aging catch basins and sewer lines are crumbling, too, some of which are so old, they're made of brick. And, of course, potholes are opening up on roads and bridges everywhere. And it isn't just happening in Chicago. The northern half of the country and even some parts of the South that were hammered by the rare Polar vortex are feeling it, too.
JAMES BROOKS: The infrastructure has taken a beating as a result of this winter and it was already in a somewhat fragile state before the cold and snow hit.
SCHAPER: James Brooks is with the National League of Cities and he says the nation as a whole has been under-investing in infrastructure for years. And he says now the added cost of fixing up what the heavy snows and bitter cold wrecked will be hefty at a time many cities budgets are just as fragile as their infrastructure.
BROOKS: They have begun to stabilize their financial health only to now be whacked again very hard by the weather at a time when they do not have the personnel in place. They do not have the equipment in the place and, obviously, they don't have the resources in place to really be able to address this fully.
SCHAPER: The American Society of Civil Engineers agrees our energy, water and transportation infrastructure is in poor shape. The group rated the overall condition of the nation's infrastructure as a D plus before this brutal winter and former ASCE president Andrew Herman says the effects of repeated freeze-thaw cycles, heavy plowing and corrosives, such as road salt, exacerbated problems.
But Herman says the chilly clouds that brought us all this misery this winter may have a silver lining of sorts.
ANDREW HERMAN: Well, I don't wish a pothole on anyone. I hope it does open their eyes that, yes, we need to do something about our infrastructure.
SCHAPER: Herman and others say this is a critical time to make greater investments in making our infrastructure more resilient, either with higher taxes, more tolls or both because climate change threatens to make our winter and summer weather more extreme. David Schaper, NPR News, Chicago. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.