FBI Nominee Agrees: Waterboarding Is 'Torture' And 'Illegal'

Jul 9, 2013
Originally published on July 9, 2013 6:44 pm

In a confirmation hearing Tuesday for James Comey to lead the FBI, the most memorable exchange FBI lasted just six seconds.

"Do you agree that waterboarding is torture and is illegal?" asked Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Patrick Leahy of Vermont.

"Yes," Comey replied.

But Comey wasn't directly asked to square that position with his approval, as deputy attorney general in the Bush years, of a 2005 Justice Department memo that concluded waterboarding detainees did not violate a U.S. anti-terrorism statute.

A few things have changed since then, national security lawyers say. In one of his first official actions, President Obama put an end to the practice of waterboarding. The White House and Attorney General Eric Holder withdrew the 2005 memo and several other war on terrorism legal analyses.

Late in 2005 — long before Obama's election — Congress passed the Detainee Treatment Act, which prohibited cruel treatment of terrorism suspects and gave immunity from prosecution to interrogators who acted on the early legal advice.

Comey would replace Robert Mueller, who is retiring in September, and administration officials say they see few major obstacles in his way. While Republican Sen. Rand Paul of Kentucky has vowed to block the nomination until he gets answers about the way the FBI uses domestic surveillance drones, a federal source tells NPR the bureau is preparing a response to try to satisfy Paul.

Copyright 2014 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.